NOVEMBER 16, 2026 – Back “[when] seldom [was] heard a discouraging word/And the skies [were] not cloudy all day” and I was a junior lawyer working in the “Special Assets” division of a large bank, one of my senior colleagues counseled wisely, “Do not take collateral that eats or [poops].” Actually, he used a synonym for “poops” that conveyed his point more forcefully.
“Special Assets,” by the way, was a euphemism for “loans in serious default.” As members of the division, our primary responsibility was to restructure loans that had tanked; to “work out” debts in default. If the workouts failed, we were tasked with pursuit of formal remedies, such as foreclosure, receiver appointments, and deficiency judgments. Ultimately, we’d be charged with managing and disposing recovered collateral hither and yon across the country—everything from half-empty strip malls in Utah to “see-through” office buildings in Dallas to apartment buildings in Nashville (constructed out of green lumber, as it turned out in one of my assignments) to fancy cars in California to fancy artwork in Minnesota to . . . a herd of grungy cattle in Montana, as was the case in my senior colleague’s portfolio, giving rise to his aversion to collateral that “eats” and “poops.”
I was on a steep learning curve, and early on, I discovered that in all too many instances, real estate “ate” and it sure “pooped.” This is not how many investors saw land and buildings, however. They saw real estate as big lever by which a relatively small amount of equity could be pressed against the fulcrum of easy debt to produce a rate of return much higher than alternative investments. The leverage alure was enhanced by favorable tax treatment of real estate, particularly depreciation and 1031 like-kind exchanges. Later, of course, came the “gravy” of a reduced tax rate on long-term capital gains.
But behind the brick façades of buildings depreciated by owners—and wholly re-depreciated from scratch by successive owners (who, trust me, never think to thank unwitting taxpayers making up for the resulting shortfalls in ordinary income tax revenues)—are a host of “eating” requirements that for in various markets and building classes, owners often can’t fully shift (if at all) to the tenants; such costs as property taxes, special assessments, casualty insurance premiums, common area maintenance and utilities. Then there’s the “pooping” part: the 20-year roof that turns out to be a 15-year roof, with the 20-year warranty having gone the way of the roofing company, which filed for bankruptcy protection 10 years before the defects appeared—with a new roof costing $400,000; or a long-time tenant that had signaled its desire to “re-up” as the lease drew to its close but was enticed away with attractive incentives by a competing building owner (who’s sucking wind and (along with its lender) desperate to increase occupancy and net operating income); or someone named George Floyd gets murdered by the cops one day, and all hell breaks loose all over town—increasing overnight, capitalization rates (and thus values) across the board.
Having worked for five years to unload “Class D” family-owned commercial real estate, I became intimately familiar with countless ways in which such property “eats” and “poops.” Looking up online prices of publicly traded securities is far easier than managing monthly cash flows and speculating wildly about ultimate value of real estate—after all additional “eating” and “pooping” to the anticipated date of closing is taken into account.
And yet . . . and yet . . . I thoroughly enjoy practicing law in the arena of commercial real estate—especially property that “eats” and “poops” more than most. In fact, what brings me the greatest professional satisfaction is the process of assessing, strategizing, and implementing workouts of troubled real estate. No two properties are the same[1], however much the themes might rhyme. Accordingly, the solutions need to be tailored to each case, though again, the general framework is similar from one situation to another.
I’m currently working with a client who owns multi-tenant commercial properties. Having walked in shoes very similar to the client’s, I’m able to understand and appreciate the spectrum of challenges and choices at play. I know “the trouble with real estate.”
I’m still loaded with self-doubt: “Am I missing something? Am I privy to all material information necessary to make a sound judgment? Is there an alternative route to resolution that I have yet to discover or develop?” But I’ve come a long way, and the best part is that if I’m answerable to my clients for how much I bill them, I’m answerable only to myself for the time I don’t bill. This control is liberating, and consequently, for me now, the practice of law is fulfilling, not burdensome. Back in the early days, I often wondered—as young lawyers are wont to do—whether there’d ever come a day when I’d enjoy the profession I’d chosen for myself.
Subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.
© 2026 by Eric Nilsson
[1] One of the first things a law student learns about real property is that the law considers each parcel of dirt and improvements thereon to be unique—giving rise to the remedy of “specific performance” in the instance of default by a buyer or seller under a purchase agreement; that is, because of the uniqueness of real estate, the proper remedy against the recalcitrant party is a court order compelling the defaulting party to perform. But this is America, and ultimately, everything is a matter of money, which is what ultimately displaces specific performance as a remedy.