CONSONANCE VS. DISSONANCE

NOVEMBER 14, 2026 – Did a time ever exist when the reader didn’t have to scrutinize the source, validity, and accuracy of written material? The simple answer is “no.” But that and a dime will get you only so far in life—and toward contextual truth.

This morning during my self-designated “free time” for reading, I stumbled across an article in the MIT Technology Review. Being as much a “techie” as my grandmother (b. 1894; d. 1994)—the one who had a driver’s license and owned the first bright yellow Toyota Corolla in Rutherford, New Jersey—was an auto mechanic, I’d never before read anything in this bi-monthly periodical published by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology but under editorial management wholly independent of the esteemed institution. If in matters of math, science and technology I’m at a sixth-grade level, the succinct article was written at about a ninth-grade level. (The target market of the magazine is the broad tech-interested public; the publication is not a scholarly journal.) On the one hand, I was proud of myself for having grasped the gist of the article. On the other hand, however, there were elements of the piece that wandered into territory where I felt less secure; where I needed to “know more” to assess the “gist.” The upshot of the article was that the threat of AI killing off the human race is way overblown. Yes, the technology is advancing rapidly, but rogue AI agents aren’t about to wipe us out. “Claims of incipient, dangerous superintelligence,” write the article’s authors, Timnit Gebru[1] and Emily M. Bender,[2] “are not based in good scientific or engineering practice. Rather, they are narratives based in ideologies of transhumanism, eugenics, and wishful thinking about imagined future digital humans.”

In other words, don’t sweat the hype. Or so we’re told by Gebru and Bender. Honestly, I possess neither the knowledge nor the fortitude to evaluate confidently their analysis or resulting conclusion; only that there’s an apparent divergent alternative—and motive—to what has whipped so many of us into a frenzy over the potential dire risks of AI. If I had greater capacity and determination, I’d reserve two hours a day to read MIT Technology Review and the tech sections of such media outlets as Bloomberg News, the Financial Times, and The Wall Street Journal, along with whole of Wired and Fast Company and comparable tech periodicals. I’d shy away from “double black diamond” engineering, science and academic journals for fear of being sucked into a giant black hole from which no light—let along a 72-year-old man of the humanities—escapes.

Given my limitations, I resort to an ad hoc approach to following tech reading material generally and on the AI front specifically. I don’t want to be left behind irretrievably or run over irreparably.

Where I find comfort and relief, however, is in old historical fiction—such as The Count of Monte Cristo. I’m well into this timeless classic by Alexandre Dumas—with the aid of Auguste Maquet. It was originally published in Journal des Débats—in serial form from 1844 to 1846. I’m reading the tome in serial fashion, as well. This thoroughly enjoyable work is to tech articles what Carnival of the Animals (1922) by Camille Saint-Saëns is to Music of Changes (1951) by composer John Cage: Consonance vs. Dissonance. The latter has its place, as does much other music (and tech writing) that’s dissonant. I don’t run from it, and in many instances I’m open to it and even embrace it. But the easier read, the more consonant the sound . . . at the sweeter end of the smörgåsbord of reading material.

Subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

 

© 2026 by Eric Nilsson

[1] Executive director of the Distributed AI Research Institute and author of Deep Unlearning: The Radicalization of a Tech Idealist.

[2] A professor of linguistics at the University of Washington, specializing in computational linguistics and natural language processing; Director of Computational Linguistics Laboratory (U of WA). Co-author (with Troy Wolverton) of The AI Con: how to Fight Big Tech’s Hype and Create the Future We Want.

 

Leave a Reply